Navigating Pay Transparency, Advertised Ranges, and Making Offers
Quick Links
As part of the university’s commitment to pay transparency and compliance with local laws, all job postings must include the minimum and maximum salary or hourly pay range for the position. This guide is designed to help hiring managers effectively navigate conversations with candidates about compensation, ensuring clarity, fairness, and professionalism during the recruitment process.
Understanding the Salary Range
The advertised salary range for each position extends from the compensation grade minimum to the compensation grade hiring maximum. This range is non-negotiable for the posting itself, and all job listings must reflect it accurately. However, it’s important to note:
- Minimum Salary: This represents the base level of compensation for a position. A candidate at the entry-level of qualifications or experience for the role may be offered a salary at or near this figure.
- Maximum Salary: This reflects the highest possible salary for the role, which the university is willing to offer for highly qualified and experienced candidates. The maximum salary is attainable but reserved for candidates whose qualifications, experience, and fit with the role are exceptional.
Key Messages for Candidates About Salary Range
When discussing the salary range with candidates, here are a few key messages to convey:
- Transparency: “As part of our commitment to transparency, the university advertises the full range of what we can pay for this role. This is required by local law and helps ensure fairness.”
- Range Flexibility: “While the posted range is broad, it reflects compensation for a wide range of qualifications and experiences. Our offer within that range will be based on your individual experience and qualifications in relation to this specific role.”
- Realistic Expectations: “The higher end of the range is reserved for candidates who bring extensive experience, specialized skills, or other qualifications that go above and beyond the basic requirements. Most candidates who meet the basic qualifications can expect an offer somewhere in the mid-range.”
Navigating Salary Conversations During the Interview Process
When salary expectations come up during the interview process, here’s how to handle these conversations confidently and transparently:
a) Before an Offer is Made: Setting Expectations Early
It’s beneficial to address salary expectations early in the interview process, helping to avoid surprises later on. You can use language like:
- “We want to be transparent about our compensation process. The advertised salary range is from [minimum] to [maximum]. Where we land within that range for any given candidate depends on their specific qualifications and experience relevant to the role.”
- “Our hiring budget typically allows for offers in the lower to mid part of this range, but we do consider the high end for candidates with extensive experience or qualifications that exceed our expectations.”
b) When a Candidate Expects the Maximum
Some candidates may assume they are entitled to the top end of the range. To manage these expectations, you can explain:
- “The maximum salary represents what we can offer a highly experienced or uniquely qualified candidate. It’s important for us to match compensation to experience and qualifications, so we’ll make our offer based on the level of expertise you bring to the position.”
- “While the range includes a high maximum, we always work within a budget for each position. Most candidates we hire tend to be in the middle of the range, unless they bring significant additional value through experience or specialized skills.”
c) Making the Offer: Framing the Decision
Once you’ve decided on the salary offer, framing it clearly will help the candidate understand the rationale behind the number:
- “Based on your experience and qualifications, we are offering you a starting salary of [offer amount], which aligns with the university’s compensation structure and reflects your fit for the role. This figure is within the advertised range and allows room for future growth.”
- “Your offer takes into account the skills and experience you bring to this position, and we believe it is competitive given the market and your qualifications. The higher end of the range is typically reserved for individuals who bring very specific and exceptional experience to the role.”
Addressing Concerns or Pushback
Some candidates may push back or express disappointment if their offer is not closer to the top of the range. Here’s how to handle such situations:
- Listen and empathize: “I understand how you feel about wanting to reach the top of the range. Let’s discuss how your qualifications align with our compensation process.”
- Restate your rationale: “The offer we made is based on your current qualifications and experience level. We believe this offer is fair and competitive within our structure and offers room for growth as you advance with us.”
- Highlight non-monetary benefits: “While the salary is important, don’t forget that our total compensation package includes additional benefits such as tuition assistance, generous paid time off including holidays, and our significant employer contribution to retirement savings. These benefits add significant value to your overall compensation.”
Post-Hire Growth and Future Compensation
It can be helpful to remind candidates that their starting salary isn’t the end of the conversation. There are opportunities for growth:
- Advancement Potential: “There are opportunities for salary increases through performance reviews, professional development, and internal advancement within the university.”
- Annual Increases and Adjustments: “Our compensation model includes regular reviews of salary ranges and performance-based adjustments, so this is just the beginning of your journey with us.”
Final Tips for Managing Salary Discussions
- Be Confident and Consistent: Candidates appreciate transparency and fairness. By confidently discussing salary expectations, you demonstrate professionalism and build trust with the candidate.
- Reinforce the Full Value of the Offer: Don’t focus solely on salary—emphasize the total compensation package, including benefits, work-life balance, and opportunities for professional development.
- Stay Calm and Positive: Salary discussions can be sensitive. Keep the conversation positive, focusing on the value the candidate brings to the role and the opportunities available to them within the organization.
By navigating salary discussions effectively, you’ll help ensure that candidates feel valued and that the university remains compliant with pay transparency laws. This approach will also help you secure great hires who are satisfied with their compensation, while maintaining the integrity of the hiring process.